Francis J Lawall And Marcy Mclaughlin

August 03, 2017 | The Legal Intelligencer

In a recently decided, but long-running dispute, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit has found that oil ­producers do not hold automatically ­perfected security interests in product they sell to midstream intermediaries, nor are the proceeds generated through the subsequent sale of such product held in an implied trust for the benefit of the upstream producers, as held in Arrow Oil & Gas v. J. Aron (In re SemCrude), 2017 U.S. App. LEXIS 12975 (3d Cir. July 19). In its ­decision, the Third Circuit determined that an automatically perfected security interest or implied trust would result in "chaos" in an industry where oil is comingled and sold multiple times in the stream of commerce.

By Francis J. Lawall 
and Marcy McLaughlin

7 minute read