The Georgia Court of Appeals has affirmed a DeKalb County judge's dismissal of a premises liability suit brought by a man stabbed repeatedly during a dustup with his ex-girlfriend.

The plaintiff was stabbed by the woman's male companion, and the courts held that the plaintiff's actions in engaging in the predawn argument left him more at fault for his injuries than the apartment complex's owner and management company.

Insley & Race partner James Myers, who defended Edgewater Apartments-Atlanta and First Communities Management with firm partner Brynda Insley, said that he was surprised the case didn't resolve earlier, given that the plaintiff should have known he was walking into trouble when he approached the screaming woman.