The Georgia Supreme Court had to watch a video of a fight between two girls in front of a high school to reach a decision Monday that both sides interpreted as a victory.

The bottom line is that, after three-and-a-half years of litigating, the Henry County Board of Education will have to take another look at its decision to expel a student for fighting and consider her claims of self-defense.

The fight happened outside the front door of Locust Grove High School after class in January 2014. The school expelled a student identified only as S.G. for violating the school's zero tolerance policy against fighting—even though she and two witnesses who worked at the school testified that the other student was the aggressor. The high court also said security video backed her up.