One of the biggest wins for Harris Lowry Manton in 2018 was an $18 million verdict for a Savannah woman who became paralyzed after being hospitalized for infection. The jury ruled for client Joan Simmons, who was 58 and had worked full-time as an accountant for Colonial Oil Group in Savannah before she became ill and went to the hospital in July 2014, according to court records.

Simmons first went to the emergency room on July 20, 2014, for acute back pain. She was treated and released, according to the plaintiff's summary in the consolidated pretrial order. She went back to the ER 10 days later, suffering from an altered mental state. She was found to have a bloodstream infection. On Aug. 5, an MRI revealed an extensive infection and abscess in her spine, according to her lawyers. She underwent decompression surgery on Aug. 6. She was discharged Sept. 11—paralyzed. Her lawyers alleged the hospital staff failed to diagnose the abscess in time to help her.

In another case, the family of camera assistant Sarah Jones reached a confidential settlement with CSX Transportation over her 2014 death while filming “Midnight Rider” near Savannah.

The undisclosed payment satisfied a $3.9 million judgment against the railroad resulting from apportionment of a total $11.2 million verdict in a 2017 trial. It's the conclusion of litigation against the last of a series of defendants involved in the train crash on the set of a movie about musician Gregg Allman.

Harris Lowry Manton represented Jones' family.

Sarah Jones was 27 when she was struck and killed on the Doctortown, Georgia, trestle. A CSX train hit the movie set where she was working on Feb. 20, 2014, according to the lawsuit. The film “Midnight Rider” was to be a biopic based on Allman's autobiography, “My Cross to Bear.”

The film's director, Randall Miller, served a year in jail after pleading guilty to involuntary manslaughter and criminal trespassing. The railroad blamed Miller and pointed out that the filmmakers were trespassing on the trestle, according to attorneys.

But, like most tragedies that wind up in litigation, firm founder Jeff Harris said, “the story was more complex.” He called the disaster “a joint mistake.”

Harris provided these answers to the Daily Report.

You've won big verdicts and collected large settlements for your clients. What factors go into counseling them on deciding between accepting a settlement and going to trial?

Ultimately, it's the client's decision about whether to accept a settlement or to go to trial. That decision depends, in large part, upon whether the offer to resolve the case is reasonable. If so, a settlement might make sense. If the settlement offer is not reasonable, we counsel our clients about the benefits of letting the jury decide. We trust juries to do the right thing.

The case for Sarah Jones' parents involved multiple defendants and criminal charges against at least one person. How do criminal charges complicate matters for lawyers on the civil litigation side?

Criminal charges can complicate matters, because it's harder to complete the discovery process while prosecutors are putting their case together. However, just because one person was criminally charged doesn't mean that other parties aren't responsible as well. We often see systemic failures that contribute to catastrophic injuries or wrongful death. One person makes a mistake, someone else doesn't catch it, and someone else doesn't follow policies or procedures that are in place. It's not unusual to see a cascade of negligence that ultimately caused the harm. You have to be honest with the jury about the fact that one party is facing criminal charges but that other parties are ultimately responsible as well.

One of your big cases this year was a medical malpractice win. What is your response to occasional calls for the state to adopt a workers' compensation-like system to address medical malpractice—where a board of experts would determine damages?

We don't believe medical malpractice cases should be singled out or treated differently than other types of cases. Medical malpractice cases are part of our civil justice system. We believe it's important to trust the jury system to resolve major issues. It's the foundation of the American judicial process.