State v. CityplaceMurray

The Supreme Court has jurisdiction over an action, if the underlying action is a murder case, regardless of whether the order appealed is based on facts, which have some bearing in the underlying criminal trial.

Thank you for sharing!

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

The State sought and this Court granted an emergency supersedeas with regard to a contempt order issued against an assistant district attorney in the underlying murder prosecution. In light of the dissenting opinion, which posits that this Court does not have jurisdiction because the finding of contempt bears no relation to the murder case, we are compelled to re-examine our longstanding order declaring that all murder cases, and all interlocutory appeals in murder cases, be transferred to this Court. State v. Thornton , 253 StateplaceGa.524 1 322 SE2d 711 1984. We conclude that we do have jurisdiction of this appeal and that the dissenters’ position is contrary to Thornton and its progeny. 1. In City placeThornton, this Court instructed the Court of Appeals to transfer all murder cases, “and all pre-conviction appeals in murder cases,” to this Court. Over the next 25 years, this Court, and the Court of Appeals, adhered to this instruction, whether or not “the judgment at issue is pre-conviction,”1 or the “appeal arises from a collateral order.”2 Thus, if “the murder count of the indictment remains pending below, jurisdiction of the appeal lies in this Court.”3

The proper focus is “on the nature of the underlying action.”4 If the underlying action is a murder case, this Court has jurisdiction of the appeal, regardless of whether the order being appealed is based on facts having some bearing on the underlying criminal trial. Thus, this Court exercised jurisdiction in a murder case where a newspaper reporter appealed from an order ruling that the reporter’s qualified privilege was inapplicable.5 Likewise, we exercised jurisdiction where, in the midst of a murder prosecution, a television station was denied media access.6

State v. CityplaceMurray

The Supreme Court has jurisdiction over an action, if the underlying action is a murder case, regardless of whether the order appealed is based on facts, which have some bearing in the underlying criminal trial.

Share with Email

Thank you for sharing!

Trending Stories

More From ALM

Subscribe to Daily Report