The Supreme Court on Dec. 3 denied an appeal by an adult Web site that sued companies providing services to sites that pirated its content.

Perfect 10, which once published a magazine but now focuses on Web content, sued companies that provided credit card billing and Web hosting services, accusing them of enabling copyright infringement and violating California target law.

Earlier this year, the 9th Circuit said such companies are shielded from liability under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and the Communications Decency Act. The High Court's decision in Perfect 10 Inc. v. CCBill will let that ruling stand.

Perfect 10 has gone after other companies it alleged enabled the pirating sites to conduct business. The 9th Circuit dismissed its suit against Visa and MasterCard this summer, while a suit it brought against search engines Google and Amazon–which allegedly led customers to the pirating sites–is still in litigation.

Perfect 10's tactic of going after companies that are indirectly contributing to the piracy rather than the actual infringing sites is novel. In an October InsideCounsel interview, Perfect 10 founder Norm Zada said targeting companies that enable the piracy is the only way a copyright owner can get relief.

“There's no reason why our banking system should be facilitating the sale of stolen movies, songs, photos, etc.,” he said. “The credit card companies don't process payments for child pornography, illegal drug sales or online gambling.”

For the rest of the interview, click here.
For more on Perfect 10's case, click here.

The Supreme Court on Dec. 3 denied an appeal by an adult Web site that sued companies providing services to sites that pirated its content.

Perfect 10, which once published a magazine but now focuses on Web content, sued companies that provided credit card billing and Web hosting services, accusing them of enabling copyright infringement and violating California target law.

Earlier this year, the 9th Circuit said such companies are shielded from liability under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and the Communications Decency Act. The High Court's decision in Perfect 10 Inc. v. CCBill will let that ruling stand.

Perfect 10 has gone after other companies it alleged enabled the pirating sites to conduct business. The 9th Circuit dismissed its suit against Visa and MasterCard this summer, while a suit it brought against search engines Google and Amazon–which allegedly led customers to the pirating sites–is still in litigation.

Perfect 10's tactic of going after companies that are indirectly contributing to the piracy rather than the actual infringing sites is novel. In an October InsideCounsel interview, Perfect 10 founder Norm Zada said targeting companies that enable the piracy is the only way a copyright owner can get relief.

“There's no reason why our banking system should be facilitating the sale of stolen movies, songs, photos, etc.,” he said. “The credit card companies don't process payments for child pornography, illegal drug sales or online gambling.”

For the rest of the interview, click here.
For more on Perfect 10's case, click here.