Runners-up honors go to Ty Buthod of Baker Botts and the rest of the trial team who defended ExxonMobil from claims brought by the family of a former gas station owner who claimed his exposure to benzene in the company's products led to his death from acute myelogenous leukemia. Following a nine-day jury trial, state court jurors in Stamford, Connecticut, last week sided with ExxonMobil on the plaintiffs' design defect and failure to warn claims, as well as on questions of causation. The company's defense team also included Jennifer Morgan and Lorey Leddy of Murtha Cullina.

Kevin Orsini, Antony Ryan, Brittany Sukiennik and Daniel Slifkin of Cravath, Swaine & Moore get a runner-up spot this week for helping financial services client Robinhood Markets Inc. fend off class certification in securities litigation tied trading restrictions for Robinhood customers during the "meme stock" short squeeze of early 2021. Plaintiffs brought market manipulation claims based on Robinhood's restrictions on customer access to certain stocks as well as company statements tying those restrictions to market volatility rather than the company's own liquidity issues. Chief U.S. District Judge Cecilia Altonaga in Miami this week denied class certification, finding that plaintiffs failed to offer a method for proving reliance class wide.  

 Runners-up honors also go to a trial team at Latham & Watkins and local co-counsel in Nevada at Robison, Sharp, Sullivan & Brust and McDonald Carano for securing a win for freelance talent platform Toptal. Jurors in Washoe County state court sided with Toptal in its claims that rival Mechanism Ventures, a company founded by tech investor Denis Grosz, interfered with Toptal's contractual relationships and awarded $535,270 in actual damages against both the company and Grosz, while also denying Grosz's counterclaims against Toptal. After returning the initial verdict Friday on Veterans Day, jurors returned to court on Saturday to award Toptal $15 million in punitive damages. The Latham team included Andrew Clubok, who handled opening and closings in the first phase of the trial, partner Kevin McDonough, associates Megan Behrman, Jarred Muller, Shannon McLaughlin, Alison Boaz, Katherine Rouse, Daniel Grill, Molly Babad and Harry McAlevey. Local co-counsel included Robison Sharp's Kent Robison, who closed on the punitive damages issue, and Hannah Winston, as well as Adam Hosmer-Henner at McDonald Carano.