They teach us in school how the three branches of government in the Constitution check and balance one another. The Bill of Rights, however, has two other checks and balances in place. Interestingly, they are in the private sector, not government. The First Amendment guarantees us the freedom of the press and the Sixth Amendment guarantees us the assistance of counsel in criminal prosecutions. These are important private sector jobs, so important they have constitutional significance and deserve special attention.

When formulating the Bill of Rights, the Founders must have realized that government cannot be counted on to check itself. They needed to go outside the three branches and enter the private sector. By establishing rights to a free press and the assistance of criminal defense counsel, regular private citizens could check all government officials on a daily basis.

A free press keeps the public informed. Without it, we could not effectively exercise our right to vote or hold elected officials accountable. It also shines a light on government fraud, waste and abuse. Whether you were a farmer, teacher or merchant in 1802 or 2002, you were busy. You needed the press to watch over government on your behalf. You could then use the information provided by the press to support your elected government officials, oppose them, or something in between. Regardless, without a free press, a majority of us would be clueless and a clueless electorate is no electorate at all. A free press also holds the judicial branch accountable, since the accused has the right to a public trial and the public has a presumptive First Amendment right of access to judicial proceedings and publicly filed court documents.

This content has been archived. It is available through our partners, LexisNexis® and Bloomberg Law.

To view this content, please continue to their sites.

Go To Lexis →

Not a Lexis Subscriber?
Subscribe Now

Go To Bloomberg Law →

Not a Bloomberg Law Subscriber?
Subscribe Now

NOT FOR REPRINT