The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit found Thursday that the New York high court's narrowing of state criminal impersonation and fraud statutes required the dismissal of some convictions in Golb v. Attorney General of the State of New York, 16-0452.

But that wasn't enough to get a Dead Sea scrolls scholar entirely off the hook for impersonating other scholars in an attempt to embarrass or do their reputations harm for disagreeing with his father's interpretation of the ancient texts.

Raphael Golb was convicted on 14 counts of criminal impersonation and 10 counts of forgery in New York Supreme Court in Manhattan over his creation of fake email accounts that sent messages impersonating other scholars. When the case was eventually heard by the state Court of Appeals in 2013, the high court ultimately found that statute was overly broad in defining injury or benefit. But it allowed nine impersonation convictions to remain, and all of the forgery convictions.