I read with interest the review in the Dec. 22 NYLJ, by attorney Howard Dworkin, of a new book written by Joel R. Brandes “The Matrimonial Trial Handbook”. Although Mr. Brandes may have extensive knowledge of matrimonial law, an important and pertinent fact was omitted from the review.

Joel R. Brandes was disbarred in New York State in 2002, sixteen years ago. He made several efforts to be reinstated to the Bar, which were denied by the Appellate Division, 2d Dept. One of the latter decisions by the court, on Dec. 17, 2012, stated “We find that Mr. Brandes does not demonstrate the requisite fitness and character to practice law.”

All of this can be verified online by reviewing the New York State courts' website, under “check attorney registration status” at www.iapps.courts.state.ny.us. In fact, the NYLJ published at least one article about Brandes' unsuccessful efforts to win reinstatement to the Bar.

In my opinion, for the sake of disclosure, transparency, objectivity and fairness, the fact that the author of the book was disbarred should have been indicated. I think knowing that important piece of information would definitely influence attorneys who are potential purchasers and readers of the book, whether to buy Brandes' book. Certainly, a lawyer would have to think twice about citing the book in motion papers and briefs in a matrimonial case, or in otherwise asking a court to rely on it.

Just like I consider wikipedia an unreliable source, personally, I would stay away from this book.

Very truly yours,
Joyce W. Behr
Attorney in Farmingdale