THE PEOPLE, res v. SEAN SUTTON, def-app

10-313/315. THE PEOPLE, res v. SEAN SUTTON, def-app — Judgment of conviction (John J. Delury, J.H.O.), rendered June 18, 2009, modified, on the law and the facts, to the extent of vacating defendant's convictions of causing unreasonable noise and operating a circulation device in excess of 42 decibels, and dismissing the accusatory instruments relating thereto; as modified, judgment affirmed.

Thank you for sharing!

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

10-313/315. THE PEOPLE, res v. SEAN SUTTON, def-app — Judgment of conviction (John J. Delury, J.H.O.), rendered June 18, 2009, modified, on the law and the facts, to the extent of vacating defendant’s convictions of causing unreasonable noise and operating a circulation device in excess of 42 decibels, and dismissing the accusatory instruments relating thereto; as modified, judgment affirmed.

Defendant was charged with, inter alia, causing unreasonable noise (see Administrative Code of City of N.Y. §24-218) and operating a circulation device in excess of 42 decibels (see Administrative Code §24-227). At the truncated Summons Part trial, the testimony of the Police Officer who issued the summonses was brief and conclusory, consisting of less than one page of testimony. The officer stated only that an “altered muffler” on defendant’s Toyota vehicle “created an unreasonable amount of noise and a loud rumbling.” This testimony was, at best, ambiguous as to the volume of the noise emanating from defendant’s vehicle and, upon our independent review of the weight of the evidence (see People v. Danielson, 9 NY3d 342 [2007]), we find it to be insufficient to establish beyond a reasonable doubt that defendant was guilty of causing “unreasonable noise” as that term is defined in the Code, namely, “any excessive or unusually loud sound that disturbs the peace, comfort or repose of a reasonable person of normal sensitivities, injures or endangers the health or safety of a reasonable person of normal sensitivities or which causes injury to plant or animal life, or damage to property or business” (Administrative Code §24-203[62]; see Administrative Code §24-218[b]; 530 W. 28th St. LP v. New York State Liq. Auth., 55 AD3d 436 [2008]; see also People v. Bakolas, 59 NY2d 51 [1983]).

THE PEOPLE, res v. SEAN SUTTON, def-app

Share with Email

Thank you for sharing!

Trending Stories

More From ALM

Subscribe to New York Law Journal