In oral arguments before the New Jersey Supreme Court on Tuesday, the justices weighed whether the refund provision created under the "Truth in Menu Act" was intended to apply only to violations involving food or to all claims of any kind brought under the Consumer Fraud Act.

A lawsuit, originally brought in 2013, was filed against five retirement communities in New Jersey—Springpoint at Monroe Village, Springpoint at Montgomery, Springpoint at Crestwood, Springpoint at Meadow Lakes and Springpoint at the Atrium.