In July 2023, 10-month-old Esther, from Wisconsin, died after swallowing a single water bead from a Chuckle & Roar Ultimate Water Beads Activity Kit purchased for an older sibling. Eight months earlier, 9-month-old Kennedy, from Maine, had to undergo multiple bowel surgeries and nearly died after swallowing a water bead from the same product.

These incidents were not “freak” occurrences. They were a predictable outcome for a product that is sold for children but is unsafe for what young children are known to do—that is, explore their world by putting objects in their mouths.