• Marshall v. SEPTA

    Publication Date: 2023-08-28
    Practice Area: Motor Vehicle Torts
    Industry: State and Local Government | Transportation
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 40 C.D. 2022

    Trial court erred in refusing to allow another state's agency to invoke sovereign immunity where constitutional principles permitted states to refuse to be sued in another state's court and there was no express statutory authority by the court waiving its immunity from suit in another state. Order of the trial court reversed, case remanded.

  • Pinnacle Amusement, LLC v. Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement

    Publication Date: 2023-07-24
    Practice Area: Administrative Law
    Industry: Entertainment and Leisure | Hospitality and Lodging | State and Local Government
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 609 - 612 C.D. 2022

    Trial court properly returned plaintiff's machines that had been seized by the bureau as gambling devices because expert testimony supported trial court's finding that the games had elements of both skill and chance and did not constitute gambling devices per se. Affirmed.

  • Penncrest Sch. Dist. v. Cagle

    Publication Date: 2023-05-08
    Practice Area: Public Records
    Industry: Education
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 1463 C.D. 2021

    Trial court erred in disregarding distinction between official and personal social media accounts and holding that public officials automatically created public records by posting about official business, as courts had to undertake fact-based analysis of social media posts to determine whether public officials were acting in an "official capacity" when posting on their personal social media accounts. Order of the trial court vacated, case remanded.

  • The Pennsylvania State Univ. v. Ward

    Publication Date: 2023-05-01
    Practice Area: Employment Litigation
    Industry: Education | State and Local Government
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 1425 C.D. 2021

    Board erred in reversing WCJ's decision because board should have remanded for clarification of WCJ's conflicting witness credibility findings and failure to detail which testimony WCJ found more credible. Vacated and remanded.

  • Young v. City of Scranton

    Publication Date: 2023-04-10
    Practice Area: Damages
    Industry: State and Local Government
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 1422 C.D. 2021

    Trial court erred in denying city's motion for JNOV and its challenge to the derivative damage award in plaintiffs' action for trespass, private nuisance, negligence and violations of the Stormwater Management Act because derivative damages for "past, present and future loss of enjoyment of their property" as well as "annoyance and inconvenience" were not permitted. Vacated and remanded.

  • Law Journal Press | Digital Book

    Florida Construction Defect Litigation 2025

    Authors: Gary L. Brown

    View this Book

    View more book results for the query "*"

  • Rickell v. Bureau of Driver Licensing

    Publication Date: 2023-03-13
    Practice Area: Criminal Law
    Industry:
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 1034 C.D. 2020

    PennDOT erred in suspending driver's operating privileges after guilty plea following revocation of Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition as suspension statute contemplated two separate, distinct offenses and driver had only one underlying DUI offense. Order of the trial court reversed.

  • Herold v. Univ. of Pittsburgh

    Publication Date: 2023-03-06
    Practice Area: Labor Law
    Industry: Education
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 998 C.D. 2021

    University appealed the denial of summary judgment to it in employee's common law claims for his workplace exposure to asbestos and development of mesothelioma and court found an exception to exclusive jurisdiction under the Occupational Disease Act for claims asserted by an employee diagnosed with an occupational disease more than four years after the employee's last workplace exposure and employee could bring civil proceedings in an appropriate court of original jurisdiction. Affirmed.

  • Martinez v. City of Reading Police Dep't

    Publication Date: 2023-02-27
    Practice Area: Public Records
    Industry: State and Local Government
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 1208 C.D. 2021

    Request for police body camera footage dismissed as moot where requestor sought the footage to use in his defense against criminal charges but requestor was ultimately acquitted of those charges, and inadequate records retention policies had been amended to prevent future inadvertent deletion of footage. Order of the trial court affirmed.

  • Reading Sch. Dist. v. Unemployment Comp. Bd. of Review

    Publication Date: 2023-02-20
    Practice Area: Employment Litigation
    Industry: Education
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 1644 C.D. 2019

    Petitioner school board appealed board's finding that claimant was justifiably provoked when she pushed janitor after janitor made a crude remark and court found board erred as a matter of law in finding justifiable provocation. Reversed.

  • Morales v. Pennsylvania Dep't of Transp.

    Publication Date: 2023-02-20
    Practice Area: Administrative Law
    Industry: State and Local Government
    Court: Commonwealth Court
    Judge: Judge Dumas
    Attorneys: For plaintiff:
    for defendant:

    Case Number: 1315 C.D. 2021

    DOT appealed trial court's order sustaining the pro se nunc pro tunc appeal of driver whose operating privilege was suspended for one year as a consequence of his refusal of chemical testing and court found trial court did not make any determination regarding driver's failure to timely file his appeal and had no jurisdiction. Vacated and remanded.