|

Before policymakers consider how to solve the student debt problem, they should know today's typical indebted college student is not the student of the past. Not only are students deeper in debt, but they are likely older, with children, and working full- or part-time as they study for a degree.

According to the National Center for Education Statistics, almost 40 percent of students enrolled for the 2019-2020 academic year are 25 or older, and 57 percent are women.

There is currently over $1.5 trillion in student debt outstanding held by 44 million borrowers, averaging more than $30,000 per student.

The impact of the growing amount of student debt — now the second largest category of consumer debt after mortgages — "has created an entire generation of a permanent debtor class which impacts the rest of their lives and the broader U.S. economy, including companies — companies and culture," according to Dan Rosensweig, president and CEO of Chegg, a publicly traded company that provides an online educational platform. 

Student loan borrowers are forced into jobs they don't want; missing payments on other debt, including auto loans and credit card debt; delaying marriage, children and home buying and, in many cases, suffering from depression and anxiety, says Rosensweig, who spoke at a recent webinar sponsored by the Aspen Institute: Unpacking $1.5 Trillion: The Real Impact of Student Loan Debt and How We Turn the Page. 

"If the burden were reduced, think about the money that could go into the pockets for housing and retirement. It would be the biggest economic boon this country has ever seen."

Help From North Texas Employers

The job market in North Texas — which includes the Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex — is red hot, causing employers to look for ways to differentiate themselves in the scramble to attract talent. A growing number, including Medical City Healthcare, Hewlett Packard Enterprise and PriceWaterhouseCoopers, are helping employees pay off their student debt.

For instance, just this year HCA HealthCare, the Nashville-based parent company of Medical City Healthcare, began paying down student debt carried by nurses, doctors, lab techs and other employees. HCA pays $150 a month for full-time employees and $75 a month for part-time employees until the loan is paid off.

Meanwhile, two North Texas lawmakers are pushing a similar benefit for police officers. State Sen. Kelly Hancock, R-North Richland Hills, passed a bill to provide up to $30,000 in loan repayment assistance funds to police officers in the state over four years, and State Rep. Lynn Stucky, R-Denton, is pushing legislation for a $20,000 individual limit to the repayment assistance program over a period of five years.

Growing Number Offering Unusual Perk

The trend is not confined to North Texas. For example, Chegg has joined a growing number of companies outside of the Lone Star State that are helping employees pay off their student debt. Its Equity for Education program provides entry-level  through manager-level employees with at least two years tenure at the company a $5,000 annual grant of company stock to help the employee pay off their student debt (employees at the director or vice president level are eligible for up to $3,000 annually).

Rosensweig is lobbying for legislative change so that the grants are not taxable for the employee and tax deductible for companies. 

Legislation has been introduced in the House, along with a companion bill in the Senate that would make that change. The Employer Participation in Repayment Act of 2019  would allow employers give tax-free student loan assistance up to $5,250 a year per employee, the same amount the tax code now treats as tax-exempt for employer-provided tuition assistance.

Abbott was able to obtain a private letter ruling from the IRS so that it could offer a program allowing the company to contribute 5 percent of an employee's salary to their 401(k) plan if the employee contributed at least 2 percent gross salary to their student loan payments. The employee is not required to contribute to their 401(k) to qualify for the Abbott contribution.

The program Freedom 2 Save program has signed up more than 1,000 employees so far, helping Abbott attract and retain talent, says Marlon Sullivan, a divisional vice president of human resources at the company, who also participated in the Aspen Institute webinar.

Reducing the Need for Student Loans

Another approach to addressing the explosion of student loan debt is to help limit the need for so much borrowing in the first place. To that end, companies like Walmart and Disney are offering debt-free college education to full and part-time employees who study online at  nonprofit online universities through Guild Education.

"This could be the next major employer benefit," says Gary Brahm, chancellor and CEO of Brandman University, which works with Guild on such programs, and also participated in the Aspen Institute webinar. It could lead to a new trend among graduating high schoolers: choosing to take a job at one of the employers who offers this benefit so they can get a college education debt-free. "This is still in the process of developing but could be a very big deal," according to Brahm.

Employers could also choose to eliminate the bachelor's of arts requirement for jobs that realistically can be done without one, requiring instead completion of a competency-based certificate program, which wouldn't cost as much time or money as a B.A., or another way a to demonstrate competency.

A number of employers in the technology area have already eliminated the bachelor's of arts requirement, according to Ajita Talwalker Menon, former special assistant for higher education policy in the Obama administration, who participated in the Aspen Institute webinar. That allows employees to borrow less and provides employers with a more  diversified talent pool. The employers found that "a B.A. wasn't a good indication that a person could perform the job," says Menon.