A bankruptcy judge in Texas refused to take up possible sanctions against plaintiff's attorney Andy Birchfield but ordered that his firm, Beasley Allen, produce communications that show how its talc clients voted on Johnson & Johnson’s proposed $10 billion prepackaged plan.

Johnson & Johnson subsidiary Red River Talc, which filed the Chapter 11 case, moved to sanction Birchfield, a principal in Montgomery, Alabama, after he failed to appear for a Nov. 18 deposition. Birchfield is a member of the Coalition of Counsel for Justice for Talc Claimants, which has challenged Johnson & Johnson’s claim that it got 83% of talc claimants to support its plan. In court documents, coalition lawyer Adam Silverstein, of Otterbourg in New York, had called the sanctions motion “overreaching and unwarranted” given that Birchfield had moved to quash his deposition and provided alternate dates to Red River Talc.