The Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court recently issued an opinion in 1400 Main Holdings v. Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission, 2024 WL 4683928, in which it held that an award of damages assessed against a landlord and a property management company by the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission (PHRC) was not supported by the evidence.

Specifically, the landlord and property management company in 1400 Main Holdings, LLC challenged the award of damages assessed against them for failure to reasonably accommodate the disability of a tenant, April Crenney, who lived in a unit at an apartment building owned by AJH and managed by Shay Carelly, the opinion said.