Manhattan attorney Robert Feldman must take down allegedly defamatory comments he made about negative online reviews that he believed were written by a former client, a state judge has ruled, though the judge declined to bar Feldman from making any such statements in the future.

The Oct. 2 ruling from Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Cynthia Kern (See Profile) in Glassman v. Feldman, 102988/12, also denied a request by the former client, second-year Brooklyn Law School student Donald Glassman, to consolidate his defamation suit against Feldman with a legal malpractice suit pending before Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Judith Gische.