As COVID fades, we are left with many important lessons. Among them, the need to recognize the importance of having a professional succession plan (professional will) in place in the event an attorney is temporarily or permanently incapacitated. Such a succession plan may also come into play in the event the attorney chooses to retire, or simply dies. Here are some pertinent provisions from the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct:

  • Rule 1.15. Safekeeping Property: This rule requires lawyers to safeguard client property and to keep complete records of client funds and property. In the event of a lawyer's incapacity or death, the lawyer's executor or other representative must take steps to protect client property.
  • Rule 1.16 Declining or Terminating Representation: This rule requires attorneys to take steps to protect their clients' interests when terminating representation. It includes the need to give reasonable notice to the client, returning client property, and refunding any unearned fees.
  • Rule 1.17 Sale of Law Practice: This rule allows lawyers to sell their legal practice in the event of retirement, disability or death. However, they must take steps to assure that clients are notified of the sale and that the clients' interests are protected.
  • Rule 1.18 Duties to Prospective Clients: Attorneys must protect the confidentiality of prospective clients and to avoid conflicts of interest. If an attorney becomes incapacitated or dies, they must take steps to ensure that the prospective clients' confidential information is protected.
  • Rule 8.01 Duty to Report: Attorneys must report professional misconduct by other attorneys. If a lawyer becomes incapacitated or dies, and the person handling their files (representative and/or executor, as applicable) finds that the attorney committed malpractice, the representative and/or attorney must report that act to the bar.
  • Rule 8.04 Misconduct: Lawyers are prohibited from engaging in certain types of misconduct, including dishonesty, fraud and misrepresentation. If an attorney becomes incapacitated or dies, their representative and/or executor may be required to report professional misconduct the attorney committed during their practice.
  • Rule 8.05 Disciplinary Authority: If an attorney becomes incapacitated or dies, their representative and/or executor may be subject to disciplinary action if they fail to take steps to protect client interests.

In addition to these professional cannons, it is important to take practical steps to ensure a smooth transition in the event of incapacity or retirement. Practical steps include:

  1. Notifying clients.
  2. Assuring client confidentiality in the course of transitioning files.
  3. Notifying malpractice carriers and making decisions regarding whether or not to obtain tail coverage. An attorney's risk of being accused of malpractice extends well beyond their last day of practice. Tail coverage is the insurance policy term that may defend an attorney against claims by former clients.
  4. Terminating leases on office rentals.

Lawyers should be prepared for personal disaster, be it occasioned by death, disability, disappearance, or force of nature. For example, in Texas, an incapacitated person includes a minor under the age of 18, or any adult who is unable to provide for his or her own food, clothing, physical health, financial affairs, or need for shelter due to physical or mental condition. Moreover, a durable power of attorney may be triggered if two physicians certify that an individual lacks the cognitive ability to make decisions regarding their physical and/or financial needs. What might indicate to others that an attorney is incapacitated?

  • Inability to understand and/or communicate with others.
  • Issues with recognizing individuals and/or objects who were familiar to them.
  • Inability to think and reason logically.
  • Signs of hallucinations and/or delusional actions.
  • Mood dysregulation.
  • Inability to understand the consequences of one's actions, due to addiction, traumatic brain injury, or mental health issues.

Who can assist a lawyer in need?

  • Law partners.
  • The lawyer's guardian.
  • The lawyer's executor.
  • A colleague at another firm who has agreed to cover cases for the attorney.
  • The lawyer's surviving spouse, if that spouse is also licensed to practice law.
  • An attorney sent in by the appropriate state bar, appointed to supervise and/or wind down the practice.
  • The individual who purchases the law practice.

Other considerations include:

  • Slowing the flow by accepting fewer cases once the decision to retire.
  • Communicating not only with clients, but with opposing counsel and the courts to communicate the change in responsibility on files.
  • Taking into account tax issues. Certain state and federal tax returns may need to be filed.
  • Selling the practice. Notice must be given, as may be required by the state bar.

What should a succession plan include?