December 06, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
The Practical Challenges of Returning Abortion Rights to Legislative ControlThe focus here will be on the significant practical issues that will arise if the court in June 2022, or sooner, announces that it has overruled Roe and Casey and how the court could address those issues in a way that was most faithful to fairly returning the subject of abortion regulation to the people through the legislative process.
By Howard J. Bashman
6 minute read
November 08, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
Only One Advocate Per Side at Oral Argument, Please (Generally Speaking)Attorneys representing different parties on the same side of an appeal, if at all possible, would likely be advancing the interests of all of their clients by trying to avoid, to the greatest extent possible, dividing the oral argument among two or more lawyers.
By Howard J. Bashman
7 minute read
October 11, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
Pennsylvania's Appellate Courts Have Their Own Shadow DocketsRecently, the U.S. Supreme Court's so-called "shadow docket" has begun to attract unprecedented attention from the news media, the U.S. Senate and the general public.
By Howard J. Bashman
6 minute read
September 13, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
Are the Consequences of a Court's Rejection of a Party's Arguments Subject to Appellate Waiver?A core principle of appellate review is that issues must first be properly raised and presented to the trial court before they can be considered and resolved on appeal. This rule of appellate waiver seeks to promote the goals of fairness and efficiency.
By Howard J. Bashman
6 minute read
August 09, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
Supreme Court Report Card: How the 3rd Circ. Fared in 2020-2021 Term (Part 2)This month's column focuses on the details of the four cases in which the Supreme Court did not agree with the Third Circuit last term.
By Howard J. Bashman
6 minute read
July 13, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
Report Card From US Supreme Court: How the Third Circuit Fared in the 2020-2021 TermDuring its just-concluded term, the Supreme Court decided six cases on direct review from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, affirming our local federal appellate court two times and reversing or vacating it four times.
By Howard J. Bashman
7 minute read
June 14, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
Catching Up on Recent Pennsylvania Appellate DevelopmentsNow that we seem to be on the verge of finally overcoming the pandemic that has understandably dominated everyone's attention over the past year and a quarter, it is the perfect time to catch up on Pennsylvania appellate developments that you may have missed.
By Howard J. Bashman
5 minute read
May 10, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
Will He Stay or Will He Go?: Calls Mount for Breyer to RetireWelcome to Stephen G. Breyer's world. He always was and remains too staid to ever reach rock star status. He is a bit too moderate, and pro-corporate interest, to constitute the perfect, stereotypical liberal Democratic appointee.
By Howard J. Bashman
6 minute read
April 05, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
2 Recent Appellate Court Rulings Show Thrill of Victory and Agony of DefeatWhen I was growing up, on Saturdays the television would often be tuned to the ABC program "Wide World of Sports," with its stirring introduction depicting both the thrill of victory and the agony of defeat. Two recent appellate court rulings, one from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, and the other from the Pennsylvania Superior Court, likewise illustrate these themes.
By Howard J. Bashman
6 minute read
March 08, 2021 | The Legal Intelligencer
No Stay of Execution on a Money Judgment? No Problem, Court Panel HoldsSenior Judge Dan Pellegrini's opinion for a unanimous three-judge panel addressed what had previously been an unresolved question of Pennsylvania law likely to be of great interest to appellate practitioners.
By Howard J. Bashman
6 minute read