Court Grants Motion for Summary Judgment in First Amendment Retaliation Claim

Lower courts erroneously dismissed adversary complaint of property owners to recover improperly withheld oil and gas royalties where property owners, not extractor, had an equitable interest in the funds, and thus a constructive trust was an appropriate mechanism for relief.

Defendants moved to dismiss plaintiff's complaint for lack of personal jurisdiction and failure to state a claim.

Court affirmed dismissal of adversary complaint by creditor where there was no evidence supporting a claim of non-dischargeability of a personal guarantee of a business loan.

Fraud Claims Dismissed; Nothing 'Unambiguously Deceptive' About Camera's Product Listing

Court imposed sanctions in the form of a factual presumption on a key issue, which defendants could only rebut with clear and convincing evidence, after defendants admittedly took no action to preserve electronically stored information in response to litigation hold notices.

Former Tenants Failed to Show Landlord's Recklessness

Appellee was fired by appellant, the Texas Health and Human Services Commission, on January 17, 2020.

Court declined to grant summary judgment for defendants where the parties' joint expert persuasively opined that plaintiffs' complaint qualified as a protective action under relevant Ecuadoran law, making plaintiffs' claims not time-barred under the Delaware borrowing statute.

Defendant moved to transfer venue to the District Court of New Jersey in plaintiff's Arizona breach of fiduciary duty and constructive fraud action.